Posted by Eventful Sweets on 3rd Jun 2025
Frosted Circus Creami
Animal Cracker Frozen Yogurt Magic
Step right up for a magical frozen treat! This Frosted Circus Creami recipe is a whimsical blend of creamy frozen yogurt and nostalgic pink & white yogurt-covered animal crackers. Made in the Ninja Creami, this colorful creation is perfect for kids, parties, or anyone craving a fun, frosty blast from the past.
The sweet crunch of circus animal cookies swirled into smooth frozen yogurt creates a carnival of flavor and texture in every bite. Whether you're a frozen yogurt fan or looking for a unique Ninja Creami recipe, this delightful dessert is guaranteed to steal the show.
It’s easy to make, bursting with vanilla and frosting vibes, and totally Instagram-worthy. This animal cracker ice cream remix is sure to bring smiles to your kitchen and become a freezer favorite. Dive into dessert nostalgia and treat yourself to a scoop (or three) of this dreamy, creamy circus magic!
Ingredients:
- 1 2/3 cups Plain Greek Yogurt (FULL Fat)
- ¼ cup Milk
- ¼ cup White Granulated Sugar
- 2 tsp Vanilla Extract (or Cake Batter Extract)
Tools:
- Ninja Creami & accessories
- Measuring Cups (Liquid and ¼ measuring cup)
- Teaspoon
- Spoons & Cups/Bowls
- Food Processor (not required) or Plastic Sandwich Bag
Instructions:
- Mix Up the Base: In the Pint container, add Yogurt, Milk, Extract of Choice, and Sugar. Mix and freeze in your freezer for 24 hours.
- Prep for Blending: Remove from the freezer and use your Ninja Creami to blend. Use the Gelato or Ice Cream Setting.
- Thin and Re-spin: Make a small well in the center of the pint and add 1-2 TBSP of milk and re-spin.
- OPTIONAL STEP: In a food processor (or plastic bag) smash up your desired amount of Animal Crackers.
- Add in the Animals: Make another well in the center of the pin and add the Animal Crackers Pink and White Yogurt Covered. Re-spin to incorporate.
- Top it off and Enjoy: Serve in a bowl and top off with more Animal Crackers. Enjoy!